2014

*PAYTON BOWL XVII*

Consolation Game

Agnostic Front

105

Terminators

88

Annihilators

94

Camquistadors

84

2013

*PAYTON BOWL XVI*

Consolation Game

Agnostic Front

98

Camquistadors

80

Purple Helmuts

101

American Tradition

70

2012

*PAYTON BOWL XV*

Consolation Game

Annihilators

84

Shockers

77

Metalhead

115

American Tradition

103

2011

*PAYTON BOWL XIV*

Consolation Game

Agnostic Front

108

Purple Helmuts

78

Faygo

102

Bottom Dwellers

68

2010

*PAYTON BOWL XIII*

Consolation Game

Buffalo Bills

69

Purple Helmuts

68

Shockers

87

Agnostic Front

82

2009

*PAYTON BOWL XII*

Consolation Game

American Tradition

105

Buffalo Bills

94

Purple Helmuts

116

Bottom Dwellers

70

2008

*PAYTON BOWL XI*

Consolation Game

Annihilators

105

American Tradition

86

Purple Helmuts

104

Big Dogs #13

64

2007

*PAYTON BOWL X*

Consolation Game

Annihilators

109

American Tradition

91

Big Dogs #13

97

Torrential Reign

82

2006

*PAYTON BOWL IX*

Consolation Game

Agnostic Front

91

Anarchy

86

W.M.B.T.W.

135

B.I.A.F.D.B.

62

2005

*PAYTON BOWL VIII*

Consolation Game

Annihilators

96

B.I.A.F.D.B.

54

Anarchy

115

Torrential Reign

104

2004

*PAYTON BOWL VII*

Consolation Game

American Tradition

88

Anarchy

66

W.M.B.T.W.

128

Stalkers

54

2003

*PAYTON BOWL VI*

Consolation Game

Mamaz Boyz

103

Anarchy

80

American Tradition

118

Annihilators

105

2002

*PAYTON BOWL V*

Consolation Game

Mamaz Boyz

89

W.M.B.T.W.

65

Wild Things

109

Agnostic Front

59

2001

*PAYTON BOWL IV*

Consolation Game

American Tradition

112

Anarchy

103

Rock Bottom

72

Annihilators

70

2000

*PAYTON BOWL III*

Consolation Game

Bud Light

158

American Tradition

143

Rock Bottom

94

Stalkers

58

1999

*PAYTON BOWL II*

Consolation Game

Hysteria

107

Rock Bottom

103

Bud Light

83

Wild Things

76

1998

*PAYTON BOWL I*

Consolation Game

American Tradition

115

Anarchy

86

Agnostic Front

84

Mamaz Boyz

70